World Vision and sports-related product donations

Over several years, World Vision U.S. has developed relationships with both Major League Baseball and the National Football League.  From those relationships, World Vision programs have benefited from their donations of time, as well as funding and products. Those resources are allocated based on program needs in both the United States and in the developing world.

More than 90 percent of our staff members come from the countries where they work, and, in many cases, reside in the communities where they serve. They are uniquely qualified to understand the needs of the children and families World Vision serves because of long-term relationships. Their understanding of a community’s needs and their ability to communicate those needs enable support offices, such as World Vision U.S., to build appropriate relationships with donors and acquire resources to meet those needs.

World Vision’s operating systems, standards, and processes help ensure that our supply chain allows for effective planning, sourcing, and delivery of all types of resources -- time, financial, and product donations. Our commitment to continuous improvement helps ensure our systems are updated as needed to meet changing needs in communities we serve, and to incorporate best-in-industry techniques to improve our effectiveness in development, and our efficiency in the supply chain.

In addition, product donations of all types in support of our education, health, and economic development -- along with disaster response programs -- are considered revenue and have accurately determined fair values. The value of these products, as well as cash and public grants, comprise data for non-profit organizations, including World Vision, to calculate overhead rates. While overhead rates represent one measure of a non-profit’s performance, they are, by no means, the primary measure of effectiveness and efficiency.

Rather, program needs -- both short-term and long-term -- comprise the primary reason World Vision accepts product donations.  Our staff determine whether to solicit or accept product donations based on requests from field offices or partner organizations; the feasibility and cost of shipping the products from the United States; and whether we can comply with any requirements of the donor. If all three of these criteria are not met, the donation will not be accepted or solicited.

Some individuals knowledgeable about the effectiveness of community programs in the developing world have contended that product donations, especially shirts and other clothing, is “bad aid,” and should play no role in the work of non-governmental organizations. Based on our more than 60 years of experience, World Vision respectfully disagrees.

Read more on the World Vision Blog about: Gifts-in-kind

Comments

experience? How about some data?

Echoing David, you would think such a powerful and influential organization in the giving community would justify its actions with statistics and facts, not something as undefinable as "experience". It's beyond disappointing that this isn't the case.

Seriously? What a terrible and weak defense of your project.

While those "individuals knowledgeable about the effectiveness of community programs" have presented solid numbers showing how introducing so many t-shirts to a local market ends up flooding the market and ultimately hurting local producers, you just go on and talk about your operating system and overheads.

At least show us numbers of how many people have benefitted. At least give us a picture of a kid wearing a superbowl shirt and feel-good narrative about how that shirt changed his life.

But seriously, just saying that based on your experience you respectfully disagree is.... I can't.

Hey World Vision. I love ya. I really do. And I support you with $$ too.

But this "argument" is nothing of the kind. There is good evidence that "aid" of this kind actually tears down local economies.

Perhaps there are situations of dire need where this type of aid is needed? That would be a great argument, particularly if backed up by some details.

But what is posted here is by no means convincing.

Leave a Comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)

Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.